*Updated October 2024
Few indulgences warm the belly and soul quite like a slice of pie. These Southern pie makers ship their freshly baked goods straight to you so that all you have to do is unbox, heat, and enjoy. On top of last year’s delicious list, you’ll see three new additions this time around!
This article contains product affiliate links. We may receive a commission if you make a purchase after clicking on one of these links.
*Listed in alphabetical order
Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop | 16 Locations Around the South!
What to order: Snickerdoodle Pie
You may have spotted (or even visited) a Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop bakery, as there are quite a few locations in the South. Owners Scott and Meredith Laytonβs pies are so popular that their company keeps growing!
Their beloved cinnamon-and sugar-laced Snickerdoodle Pie could just as easily be served for breakfast as dessert, and it’s a hit around the holidays. All of this shop’s pies are baked to order and tend to sell out close to the holidays, so be sure to place your order in advance HERE.
Cootie Brownβs | Johnson City, TN
What to order: Pumpkin Pie Cheesecake
Cootie Brownβs in East Tennessee is well-known for its two-layer pies, including this seasonal favorite β a cheesecake pie made from scratch with real pumpkin, cream cheese, and a traditional blend of pumpkin pie spices. The cheesecake holds up well for up to six months in the freezer, so place your order ASAP HERE.
Georgiaβs Sweet Potato Pie Co. | Louisville, KY
What to order: Sweet Potato Pie
Dawn Urrutia of Georgiaβs Sweet Potato Pie Co. has been serving pies with a purpose (plus cookies, cupcakes, and other goodies) to the Louisville community since 2016. The proceeds from her bakeshop sales and nationwide deliveries help her team of volunteers support local nonprofits and donate products at community events throughout the year. Order a pie AND make a difference HERE.
Haydel’s | New Orleans, LA
What to order: Maple Syrup Pecan Pie
Though best known for its King Cakes, Haydel’s Bakery in New Orleans also makes a mean pecan pie. You’ll see a few spins on pecan pie on this list, but this one is laced with maple syrup for an added touch of cozy richness. You can order yours HERE. (Their petit fours make fabulous holiday gifts, too!)
Kermitβs Key West Key Lime Shoppe | Key West, FL
What to order: Key Lime Pie
Looking for something a little more tropical? Kermitβs famous Key Lime Pie is made with an in-house double-strength key lime juice in a rich, tart filling, set in a traditional graham cracker crust, and topped with fluffy whipped cream. Order one to infuse your next holiday party with a bit of sunshine.
To ensure the freshest product, Kermitβs ships all pies via overnight delivery (Monday through Thursday) with a strict order cutoff of 1 p.m. EST. Order HERE.
Kernβs Kitchen | Louisville, KY
What to order: Derby Pie
A beloved Kentucky tradition, the Derby Pie from Kernβs Kitchen has been served on Southern holiday tables since the 1950s. Though the company has grown by leaps and bounds since then, each pie is still carefully handcrafted, one at a time, in their Louisville, KY, bakery. Their famous Derby Pie is baked from a secret recipe, but we know itβs laced with plenty of chocolate and walnuts. Order yours HERE.
Pearson Farm | Fort Valley, GA
What to order: Custard Pecan Pie
There are so many layers of goodness in this pecan-topped pie. It starts with a creamy custard base made with eggs, buttermilk, and real butter, and itβs topped with a crusty pecan layer loaded with flavor and texture. These pies are made right on-property at Pearson Farm, and you can order yours HERE!
Priesterβs | Fort Deposit, AL
What to order: Classic Pecan Pie
If youβre a pecan pie purist, this might be the pie for you. Since 1935, Priesterβs has been a beloved purveyor of all things pecans. They make everything the old-fashioned way: by hand. Your guests will love you after they try this pecan pie. Place your orders HERE.
Red Truck Bakery | Warrenton, VA
What to order: Virginia Peanut Pie
Virginia’s famous peanuts shine in this chocolatey, nutty pie laced with dark chocolate ganache, caramel, and Virginia hickory syrup, then finished with a sprinkle of sea salt. Order yours from Virginia’s acclaimed Red Truck Bakery HERE. They also ship their wildly popular coffee beans, cakes, and cookbooks, so you can stock up on a few gifts while you’re at it!
Royers Pie Haven | Round Top, TX
What to order: Texas Trash Pie
Bud βThe Piemanβ Royer and his family moved to Round Top in 1987 to take over the tiny, 40-seat Round Top CafΓ©, which they quickly turned into an iconic destination and highly acclaimed Texas bistro. If you canβt get to the funky town of Round Top to try the pie straight from the hands of the Royers themselves, theyβll ship one to your doorstep. Order HERE!
Slice Pie Company | Raleigh, NC
What to order: Apple Pie
Slice Pie Companyβs super-flaky pie crust recipe has been passed down through generations. After years of tweaking the recipe, Raleigh native Michael Mullins entered his apple pie into the North Carolina State Fair, and it won! Slice Pie Company has been baking pies since 2014, and you can ship one to yourself or a loved one by ordering HERE.
Three Brothers Bakery | Houston, TX
What to order: Chocolate Bourbon Pecan Pie
Three Brothers Bakery began in Europe 200 years ago and has since become a Houston institution best known for its traditional Jewish bread, cookies, pies, cupcakes, custom cakes, and more.
The Chocolate Bourbon Pecan Pie is housed in a scratch-made pie crust, filled with Southern pecans, and coated with their chocolate Jack Danielβs bourbon pie filling. Itβs one of four award-winning pecan pies on their roster. They even offer personalized box options! Shop these seriously famous (and delicious) pies HERE.
Tiny Pies | Austin, TX
What to order: Pumpkin Pie
You didn’t think we’d let you go without at least one traditional pumpkin pie, did you? This cozy autumn classic is available from Tiny Pies in Austin, TX, and yes β there’s a tiny option, too.
Tiny Pies was founded in 2011 β within the walls of the Delta Delta Delta sorority house at UT Austin β by Amanda Wadsworth and her mother, Kit Seay, who was the House Mother at the time. You can find both regular-sized pumpkin pies and tiny ones HERE.
Save us a slice, will ya!?
**********
For more gift ideas, seasonal recipes, and entertaining inspiration, follow us on Pinterest!