Whether for a gathering during football season, a buffet during March Madness, or a sandwich you’re just making because it’s Saturday and you want to splurge, look no further than The Ultimate Southern Sandwich. We’ll start with the ingredients and then tell you the interesting story behind the brands.
Ingredients:
- Palmetto Pimento Cheese with Jalapeños
- Duke’s Mayonnaise
- Wickles Pickles
- Conecuh Sausage
- Slider buns
- Optional: Tomatoes if the season is right
Instructions:
Warm the slider buns and split down the middle. While they are warming, cook the Conecuh sausage in a frying pan — cast iron preferred — until cooked through. Then, assemble the slider sandwiches with Palmetto Pimento Cheese with Jalapenos, Wickles Pickles, Conecuh Sausage and some Duke’s Mayonnaise for good measure.
Two slider sandwiches per person are recommended.
Palmetto Pimento Cheese & Duke’s Mayonnaise: South Carolina Roots
Personally, I can not keep Palmetto Pimento Cheese with Jalapenos in my house as when I know it’s in the refrigerator, I become completely distracted. For some people, it’s chips, for others it’s ice cream. For me, it’s this particular brand of pimento cheese — with the jalapeños in it — which I promise has a voice that calls out to me, “I’m here … eat more of me … you love me … OPEN UP THE REFRIGERATOR!” And, my favorite mayonnaise, hands down, is Duke’s. It has a particular tang that I like better than all other mayos. What I did not realize until recently is that both companies share some overlap in their company history.
With a brand that has lasted more than a century, Duke’s Mayonnaise originated in 1917 when Eugenia Duke started selling her homemade sandwiches to soldiers in Greenville, South Carolina, who were training at nearby Camp Sevier as America was in the midst of World War One. Her sandwiches were a hit, and the mayonnaise, slathered across each one, was the star. By 1923, she bottled the mayonnaise and started selling it as a separate business; she sold her sandwich company, Duke Sandwich Company, to her accountant, J. Allen Hart. However, she could not keep up with the high demand for Duke’s Mayonnaise and sold the mayonnaise brand in 1929 to C.F. Sauer Company, based in Richmond, Virginia. Duke’s is now available nationwide as well as in New Zealand, Australia and parts of the Middle East.
And that Duke Sandwich Company that Eugenia sold to her accountant? Well, that company is still in the same family and has expanded to include three locations in Greenville, SC. They also have expanded their manufacturing capabilities in several ways under parent company Duke Sandwich Productions. One of the products that Duke Sandwich Productions is responsible for producing is Palmetto Pimento Cheese, to the tune of more than 120,000 containers each week at its South Carolina facility!
Just how did this delicious pimento cheese originate? Sassy Henry was living in Atlanta and mixing up batches of this spread for tailgating at Braves’ games. She and her husband moved to Pawleys Island, South Carolina, with their two children in 2002 to run the Sea View Inn. This recipe continued to be used as part of the menu served to guests. In 2006 it was available at local stores on Pawleys Island and the surrounding area. Now it is widely available across the entire country.
Wickles Pickles & Conecuh Sausage: Alabama Roots
I married a man from Sylacauga, Alabama. What this means is that I’ve been brainwashed to pick a side (Auburn or Alabama), have heard his family wax poetic about the virtues of a Chilton County peach and have been indoctrinated into the world of Conecuh Sausage. In fact, up until a few years ago when Conecuh Sausage became available outside the Alabama state line, we would travel home with some Conecuh Sausage, and my in-laws would bring it with them on visits as well. That’s just what one did.
The Sessions family has been smoking Conecuh Sausage in Evergreen, Alabama, since 1947. Evergreen is about 80 miles southeast of Montgomery, just off of I-65, in Conecuh County. And, instead of my in-laws carrying some up with them each time they visit, we can now go to the local grocery and pick some up. See this store locator to purchase some and taste why it’s considered an iconic Southern food.
These four brands, from South Carolina and Alabama, make The Ultimate Southern Sandwich possible. Substitute brands are not allowed!
Enjoy!
***********
Find more tasty recipes in our archives. Click HERE!
Originally published in 2018, updated in 2023
